Correction: Aquaponic trends, configurations, operational parameters, and microbial dynamics: a concise review

Metadata

• Cite key: kushwahaAquaponicTrendsConfigurations2024
• Item type: Journal Article — this is a formal Correction/Erratum notice (Zotero “Type” field = “Correction”; Crossref type = “journal-article” but subtype “correction”), NOT the original research/review article.
• Authors: J. Kushwaha, M. Priyadarsini, J. Rani, K. P. Pandey, A. S. Dhoble
• Affiliation: School of Biochemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology (BHU), Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh 221005, India
• Journal: Environment, Development and Sustainability Vol. 27, Issue 2 (2024) p. 5443
• Date: 07/2024
• Date added: [not reported]
• DOI: 10.1007/s10668-024-05254-5
• Funding: [not reported]
• URL: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-024-05254-5
• PDF: Kushwaha et al. - 2024 - Correction Aquaponic trends, configurations, oper.pdf

Opinion

This PDF is a one-page publisher correction notice, not the article itself. It corrects the original review article “Aquaponic trends, configurations, operational parameters, and microbial dynamics: a concise review” (same author team), published in the same journal, DOI 10.1007/s10668-023-03924-4, Environment, Development and Sustainability 27(1):213–246 (2023-10-04) — confirmed via Crossref lookup of that DOI. The correction adds a missing acknowledgement/credit line (“Created with BioRender.com”) to Figures 3 and 4 of the original article. It contains no abstract, no data, no methods, and no findings of its own — there is nothing substantive to extract from this PDF beyond documenting that the correction exists and what it fixes. The original 2023 review article does not appear to be present yet in this vault (zotero-export.csv and notes/ contain no entry for it) and would need to be separately sourced and extracted on its own merits if the reviewer wants its actual review content (aquaponic configurations, operational parameters, microbial dynamics).

Abstract

[not reported] — this correction notice has no abstract. The two-page PDF consists solely of the correction statement and Springer Nature’s standard terms-of-use boilerplate.

Summary

This is a formal correction to Kushwaha et al.’s 2023 review “Aquaponic trends, configurations, operational parameters, and microbial dynamics: a concise review” (Environ Dev Sustain 27(1):213–246). The correction states that the original publication omitted an acknowledgement text and a “Created with BioRender.com” credit line for Figures 3 and 4. It reprints the corrected captions: Figure 3 (“Different aquaponics configurations: a pilot-scale, b decoupled, c coupled, d multiloop, e small-scale”) and Figure 4 (“High-throughput techniques for examining microbial diversity in aquaponics”), both now crediting BioRender.com, plus a standalone acknowledgment line. No scientific content, data, or review findings are restated or amended — the correction is purely an attribution/credit fix, unrelated to the substance of the original review.

---

---

Extraction notes

• Handling decision: Confirmed by reading both PDF pages that this is genuinely a bare correction notice (Scenario 1 in the task brief), not a republished full article. Total substantive content is two sentences plus two corrected figure captions and one acknowledgment line.
• The original article it corrects (DOI 10.1007/s10668-023-03924-4, same title minus “Correction:”, same 5 authors, Environ Dev Sustain 27(1):213–246, published 2023-10-04) was checked for in zotero-export.csv (no match by title) and in notes/ (no kushwaha* files existed prior to this note) — it is not yet in the vault. This note therefore cannot inherit or backfill any review content from it without guessing, per the prime directive.
• No trials.csv or plant_measurements.csv rows produced: this is neither experiment, quasi-experiment, field-trial, nor exploratory — it is not even a review with content, just a correction notice. trials: 0 in frontmatter is accurate.
• type: narrative-review was chosen as the best available classification for what the underlying corrected work is (a “concise review” per its own title, with no stated systematic search strategy visible from this notice — that would need confirming from the original article’s own methods section, which is [not reported] here). This note carries no primary-research marker, consistent with CLAUDE.md’s rule against mixing review and primary-research markers.
• quality: left blank — not set, since this is not a CSV-producing/extractable-data paper.
• Value added to the vault: This note documents that (a) a correction exists for the Kushwaha et al. review, (b) what specifically it fixes (figure attribution only, no scientific content), and (c) that the underlying 2023 original review is still missing from the vault and should be sourced separately if its actual review content (aquaponic configurations, operational parameters, microbial dynamics synthesis) is wanted for this literature review. Without this note, a future pass could mistake this PDF for the primary source and either skip the real review or wrongly treat this stub as covering its content.

---

Source: Kushwaha et al. - 2024 - Correction Aquaponic trends, configurations, oper.pdf